3scale API Management and Axway AMPLIFY API Management compete in the API management category. While 3scale excels in deployment ease and containerization, Axway holds the advantage in security and governance.
Features: 3scale API Management is noted for its lightweight design, ease of deployment, particularly in containerized environments like OpenShift, and user-friendly API automation and security features. Axway AMPLIFY API Management provides robust security and governance features, excels in handling large data volumes efficiently, and supports extensive cross-system API management.
Room for Improvement: 3scale API Management faces challenges with customization, limited API support, and complexity in managing content through its CMS. The reliance on liquid templates can also be difficult for some developers. Axway AMPLIFY API Management needs improvement in scalability, technical support, and additional features like "Revision History" for API flows.
Ease of Deployment and Customer Service: 3scale API Management offers a seamless deployment experience on various platforms, including on-premises and hybrid cloud environments, but receives mixed reviews for customer service. Axway AMPLIFY API Management is praised for its responsive technical support and supports multiple deployment models, focusing on stability and broader system integration.
Pricing and ROI: 3scale API Management is considered affordable, especially when bundled with OpenShift, offering good value for mid-sized clients. Axway AMPLIFY API Management is perceived as more expensive but justified by its comprehensive features and security capabilities. Both solutions provide a positive ROI, with 3scale appealing to cost-conscious users and Axway to clients needing extensive features.
I have seen a return on investment through faster API delivery and greater governance, with my development team now spending less time managing API security and access control manually.
After standardizing authentication and gateway policy checks, the time needed to execute our core API regression suite decreased by roughly twenty to twenty-five percent.
We have an engagement partner from Axway, and their technical and product teams are very supportive whenever we need clarifications or urgent confirmations.
If they understand that an issue is a bug or something that needs to be improved in their tool, they take it as improvement feedback and deploy patches in the next update.
A better turnaround time for non-critical tickets would be beneficial, as I sometimes have to wait three to five days for an issue to be resolved.
I can expand the platform without making significant changes to the overall architecture.
The scalability of Axway AMPLIFY API Management is also great, and I would rate it around eight, given that we have scaled it up to twenty-eight hundred to thirty-five hundred APIs hosted on the gateway without performance degradation.
Regarding scalability for Axway AMPLIFY API Management, it can scale up to N servers.
I would rate the stability of Axway AMPLIFY API Management at around nine or nine point five, as we have not experienced any outages, and performance testing shows CPU utilization barely reaching seven to ten percent even under heavy loads.
Since banking and financial organizations prefer to use it, their preference validates its stability.
During high traffic periods, the dashboard struggles to load, and the system can go down, which complicates reporting and analysis.
When there is a very large volume or very large number of transactions going on live in production, sometimes it purges the previous data very quickly, leaving only one or two hours of data.
When we modify the API and resend it back to the server, we need to do several checks again to ensure that the API received from the target server works normally and that what we modified from the API is acceptable.
Better analytics and reporting capabilities should provide improved trackability for API performance and consumer behavior.
This model provides a cap of around one hundred fifty thousand calls per month that gives us the flexibility to host many gateways but at a cost based on production traffic.
It is an expensive tool at the time of purchase and licensing.
The pricing for Axway AMPLIFY API Management is quite high for small companies, organizations, or teams.
It simplifies exposing our APIs externally and inherently adds a layer of security, which I see as a positive impact from the product.
Its policy management feature capabilities are excellent, making it very easy to enforce security and governance standards across all APIs, and the developer portal is a very useful feature that helps my team discover and efficiently consume APIs.
The feature I rely on most in Axway AMPLIFY API Management is policy-based security and access control because from a QA perspective, it gives me a consistent way to test authentication and authorization scenarios at the gateway level before requests reach the backend.
Axway AMPLIFY API Management sits in the DMZ zone, outside the security firewalls of the organization, allowing us to intercept all calls originating from external sources, validate and check for threats, including SQL injection attacks, malware, and potential spamming from excessive API calls that could deny legitimate users access.
| Product | Mindshare (%) |
|---|---|
| Axway AMPLIFY API Management | 1.6% |
| 3scale API Management | 1.8% |
| Other | 96.6% |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 6 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 2 |
| Large Enterprise | 5 |
| Company Size | Count |
|---|---|
| Small Business | 4 |
| Midsize Enterprise | 2 |
| Large Enterprise | 12 |
3scale API Management offers a streamlined approach to API exposure, focusing on robust security and seamless integration with OpenShift. Its lightweight deployment is compatible with both on-premises and cloud environments, facilitating API automation and centralized traffic control.
Designed to manage both internal and external APIs, 3scale API Management provides a containerized gateway that supports microservice architectures. Its integration with ESB networks and compatibility with OpenShift for simple deployment make it desirable for organizations in need of flexible API management. Although appreciated for its security features and ease of installation, challenges persist in its developer portals and CMS usability. The platform supports container deployment and offers centralized policy management and traffic oversight, but there are areas requiring improvement, such as SOAP support and UI simplicity.
What key features does 3scale API Management offer?3scale API Management is utilized across financial and service communication sectors where secure and efficient API management is critical. Companies implement it within hybrid environments, often using AWS for additional management capabilities. Its application in these industries helps maintain secure exposure and traffic monitoring of APIs, pivotal in maintaining organizational efficiency.
Axway AMPLIFY API Management offers secure and user-friendly API management solutions supporting flexible deployment options while ensuring robust security for data exchange and centralized management for developers.
Axway AMPLIFY API Management emphasizes strong security measures against threats, facilitating authenticated data exchange. Its centralized management tools enable efficient API analytics and portal usage. The platform's flexible deployment options, including on-premise and cloud solutions, are coupled with a user-friendly interface featuring drag-and-drop functionalities to streamline operations. However, improvements are needed in Amplify Central portal, customization features, and scalability options. While used primarily as an API gateway for internet, web, and REST APIs, companies leverage its features to create secure connections and integrate APIs internally and externally, fostering a comprehensive API ecosystem.
What are the key features of Axway AMPLIFY API Management?In the financial services industry, Axway AMPLIFY API Management is integral in creating secure marketplaces and ensuring reliable communication among partners. Its robust security and hybrid-cloud capabilities make it ideal for creating sophisticated API ecosystems, facilitating both internal and external integrations essential for modern operations.
We monitor all API Management reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.
